Modify arithmetic problem formats to make the relational equation structure more transparent. We describe this practice and three additional evidence-based practices: (1) introducing the equal sign outside of arithmetic, (2) concreteness fading activities, and (3) comparing and explaining different problem formats and problem-solving strategies.

Alibali, Martha W., and LizaMeredith. 2009. “Sources of Change in Children’s Encoding of Mathematics Problems.” In Understanding Knowledge Change: Investigations on How Children Learn Mathematics and Literary Skills, Symposium Presented at the Sixth Biennial Meeting of the Cognitive Development Society, edited by BethanyRittle-Johnson, San Antonio, TX, October 16–17, 2009.

Alibali, Martha W., and LizaMeredith. 2009. “Sources of Change in Children’s Encoding of Mathematics Problems.” In )| false

Ball, Deborah Loewenberg.1993. “With an Eye on the Mathematical Horizon: Dilemmas of Teaching Elementary School Mathematics.” Elementary School Journal93, no. 4 (March): 373–97.

Ball, Deborah Loewenberg.1993. “With an Eye on the Mathematical Horizon: Dilemmas of Teaching Elementary School Mathematics.” )| false

Baroody, Arthur J., and Herbert P.Ginsburg. 1983. “The Effects of Instruction on Children’s Understanding of the ‘Equals’ Sign.” Elementary School Journal84, no. 2 (November): 198–212.

Baroody, Arthur J., and Herbert P.Ginsburg. 1983. “The Effects of Instruction on Children’s Understanding of the ‘Equals’ Sign.” )| false

Booth, Julie L.,
Karin E.Lange,
Kenneth R.Koedinger, and Kristie J.Newton. 2013. “Using Example Problems to Improve Student Learning in Algebra: Differentiating between Correct and Incorrect Examples.” Learning and Instruction25 (June): 24–34.

Booth, Julie L.,
Karin E.Lange,
Kenneth R.Koedinger, and Kristie J.Newton. 2013. “Using Example Problems to Improve Student Learning in Algebra: Differentiating between Correct and Incorrect Examples.” )| false

Carpenter, Thomas P.,
Megan LoefFranke, and LindaLevi. 2003. Thinking Mathematically: Integrating Arithmetic and Algebra in Elementary School. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

Carpenter, Thomas P.,
Megan LoefFranke, and LindaLevi. 2003. )| false

Charles, Randall I.2005. “Big Ideas and Understandings as the Foundation for Elementary and Middle School Mathematics.” National Council for Supervisors of Mathematics: Journal of Mathematics Education Leadership7, no. 3 (Spring-Summer): 9–24.

Charles, Randall I.2005. “Big Ideas and Understandings as the Foundation for Elementary and Middle School Mathematics.” )| false

Chi, Michelene T. H.2009. “Active‐Constructive‐Interactive: A Conceptual Framework for Differentiating Learning Activities.” Topics in Cognitive Science1, no. 1 (January): 73–105.

Chi, Michelene T. H.2009. “Active‐Constructive‐Interactive: A Conceptual Framework for Differentiating Learning Activities.” )| false

Falkner, Karen P.,
LindaLevi, and Thomas P.Carpenter. 1999. “Children’s Understanding of Equality: A Foundation for Algebra.” Teaching Children Mathematics6, no. 4 (December): 232–36.

Falkner, Karen P.,
LindaLevi, and Thomas P.Carpenter. 1999. “Children’s Understanding of Equality: A Foundation for Algebra.” )| false

Fyfe, Emily R.,
Nicole M.McNeil, and StephanieBorjas. 2015. “Benefits of ‘Concreteness Fading’ for Children’s Mathematics Understanding.” Learning and Instruction35 (February): 104–20.

Fyfe, Emily R.,
Nicole M.McNeil, and StephanieBorjas. 2015. “Benefits of ‘Concreteness Fading’ for Children’s Mathematics Understanding.” )| false

Hornburg, Caroline Byrd,
Brianna L.Devlin, and Nicole M.McNeil. “Earlier Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence in Elementary School Predicts Greater Algebra Readiness in Middle School.” (submitted).

Hornburg, Caroline Byrd,
Brianna L.Devlin, and Nicole M.McNeil. “Earlier Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence in Elementary School Predicts Greater Algebra Readiness in Middle School.” (submitted).)| false

Hughes, Elizabeth M.,
Sarah R.Powell, and Elizabeth A.Stevens. 2016. “Supporting Clear and Concise Mathematics Language: Instead of That, Say This.” Teaching Exceptional Children49, no. 1 (October): 7–17.

Hughes, Elizabeth M.,
Sarah R.Powell, and Elizabeth A.Stevens. 2016. “Supporting Clear and Concise Mathematics Language: Instead of That, Say This.” )| false

Jacobs, Victoria R.,
Megan LoefFranke,
Thomas P.Carpenter,
LindaLevi, and DanBattey. 2007. “Professional Development Focused on Children’s Algebraic Reasoning in Elementary School.” Journal for Research in Mathematics Education38, no. 3 (May): 258–88.

Jacobs, Victoria R.,
Megan LoefFranke,
Thomas P.Carpenter,
LindaLevi, and DanBattey. 2007. “Professional Development Focused on Children’s Algebraic Reasoning in Elementary School.” )| false

Jones, Ian,
MatthewInglis,
CamillaGilmore, and MargaretDowens. 2012. “Substitution and Sameness: Two Components of a Relational Conception of the Equals Sign.” Journal of Experimental Child Psychology113, no. 1: 166–76.

Jones, Ian,
MatthewInglis,
CamillaGilmore, and MargaretDowens. 2012. “Substitution and Sameness: Two Components of a Relational Conception of the Equals Sign.” )| false

Knuth, Eric J.,
Ana C.Stephens,
Nicole M.McNeil, and Martha W.Alibali. 2006. “Does Understanding the Equal Sign Matter? Evidence from Solving Equations.” Journal for Research in Mathematics Education37 , no. 4 (July): 297–312.

Knuth, Eric J.,
Ana C.Stephens,
Nicole M.McNeil, and Martha W.Alibali. 2006. “Does Understanding the Equal Sign Matter? Evidence from Solving Equations.” )| false

Lampert, Magdalene.1990. “When the Problem Is Not the Question and the Solution Is Not the Answer: Mathematical Knowing and Teaching.” American Educational Research Journal27, no. 1: 29–63.

Lampert, Magdalene.1990. “When the Problem Is Not the Question and the Solution Is Not the Answer: Mathematical Knowing and Teaching.” )| false

Li, Xiaobao,
MeixiaDing,
Mary MargaretCapraro, and Robert M.Capraro. 2008. “Sources of Differences in Children’s Understandings of Mathematical Equality: Comparative Analysis of Teacher Guides and Student Texts in China and the United States.” Cognition and Instruction26, no. 2: 195–217.

Li, Xiaobao,
MeixiaDing,
Mary MargaretCapraro, and Robert M.Capraro. 2008. “Sources of Differences in Children’s Understandings of Mathematical Equality: Comparative Analysis of Teacher Guides and Student Texts in China and the United States.” )| false

Matthews, Percival G., and Lynn S.Fuchs. 2020. “Keys to the Gate? Equal Sign Knowledge at Second Grade Predicts Fourth‐Grade Algebra Competence.” Child Development91, no. 1: e14–e28.

Matthews, Percival G., and Lynn S.Fuchs. 2020. “Keys to the Gate? Equal Sign Knowledge at Second Grade Predicts Fourth‐Grade Algebra Competence.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M., and Martha W.Alibali. 2004. “You’ll See What You Mean: Students Encode Equations Based on Their Knowledge of Arithmetic.” Cognitive Science28, no. 3: 451–66.

McNeil, Nicole M., and Martha W.Alibali. 2004. “You’ll See What You Mean: Students Encode Equations Based on Their Knowledge of Arithmetic.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M., and Martha W.Alibali. 2005. “Why Won’t You Change Your Mind? Knowledge of Operational Patterns Hinders Learning and Performance on Equations.” Child Development76 (July/August): 883–99.

McNeil, Nicole M., and Martha W.Alibali. 2005. “Why Won’t You Change Your Mind? Knowledge of Operational Patterns Hinders Learning and Performance on Equations.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M.,
Emily R.Fyfe, and April E.Dunwiddie. 2015. “Arithmetic Practice Can Be Modified to Promote Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” Journal of Educational Psychology107, no. 2: 423–36.

McNeil, Nicole M.,
Emily R.Fyfe, and April E.Dunwiddie. 2015. “Arithmetic Practice Can Be Modified to Promote Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M.,
Emily R.Fyfe,
Lori A.Petersen,
April E.Dunwiddie, and HeatherBrletic-Shipley. 2011. “Benefits of Practicing 4 = 2 + 2: Nontraditional Problem Formats Facilitate Children’s Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” Child Development82, no. 5 (September/October): 1620–33.

McNeil, Nicole M.,
Emily R.Fyfe,
Lori A.Petersen,
April E.Dunwiddie, and HeatherBrletic-Shipley. 2011. “Benefits of Practicing 4 = 2 + 2: Nontraditional Problem Formats Facilitate Children’s Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M.,
CarolineByrd Hornburg,
Brianna L.Devlin,
CristinaCarrazza, and Mary O.McKeever. 2019. “Consequences of Individual Differences in Children’s Formal Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” Child Development90, no. 3: 940–56.

McNeil, Nicole M.,
CarolineByrd Hornburg,
Brianna L.Devlin,
CristinaCarrazza, and Mary O.McKeever. 2019. “Consequences of Individual Differences in Children’s Formal Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence.” )| false

McNeil, Nicole M.,
CarolineByrd Hornburg,
HeatherBrletic-Shipley, and Julia M.Matthews. 2019. “Improving Children’s Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence via an Intervention that Goes beyond Nontraditional Arithmetic Practice.” Journal of Educational Psychology111, no. 6: 1023–44.

McNeil, Nicole M.,
CarolineByrd Hornburg,
HeatherBrletic-Shipley, and Julia M.Matthews. 2019. “Improving Children’s Understanding of Mathematical Equivalence via an Intervention that Goes beyond Nontraditional Arithmetic Practice.” )| false

National Governors Association Center for Best Practices (NGA Center) and Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO). 2010. Common Core State Standards for Mathematics. Washington, DC: NGA Center and CCSSO. http://www.corestandards.org.

National Governors Association Center for Best Practices (NGA Center) and Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO). 2010. )| false

Perry, Michelle,
R.Breckinridge Church, and SusanGoldin-Meadow. 1988. “Transitional Knowledge in the Acquisition of Concepts.” Cognitive Development3, no. 4: 359–400.

Perry, Michelle,
R.Breckinridge Church, and SusanGoldin-Meadow. 1988. “Transitional Knowledge in the Acquisition of Concepts.” )| false

Renwick, E. M.1932. “Children’s Misconceptions Concerning the Symbols for Mathematical Equality.” British Journal of Educational Psychology2, no. 2 (June): 173–83.

Renwick, E. M.1932. “Children’s Misconceptions Concerning the Symbols for Mathematical Equality.” )| false

Siegler, Robert S.2002. “Microgenetic Studies of Self-Explanations.” In Microdevelopment: Transition Processes in Development and Learning, edited by NiraGranott and JimParziale, pp. 31–58. New York: Cambridge University.

Siegler, Robert S.2002. “Microgenetic Studies of Self-Explanations.” In )| false

Stephens, Ana,
MariaBlanton,
EricKnuth,
IsilIsler, and Angela MurphyGardiner. 2015. “Just Say Yes to Early Algebra!” Teaching Children Mathematics22, no. 2 (September): 92–101.

Stephens, Ana,
MariaBlanton,
EricKnuth,
IsilIsler, and Angela MurphyGardiner. 2015. “Just Say Yes to Early Algebra!” )| false

Weaver, J. Fred.1973. “The Symmetric Property of the Equality Relation and Young Children’s Ability to Solve Open Addition and Subtraction Sentences.” Journal for Research in Mathematics Education4, no. 1 (January): 45–56.

Weaver, J. Fred.1973. “The Symmetric Property of the Equality Relation and Young Children’s Ability to Solve Open Addition and Subtraction Sentences.” )| false